Do the Proposed USDA Hemp Rules Threaten Our CBD Industry?

We’re hearing concerns from some farmers and CBD manufacturers that the proposed USDA hemp rules, released earlier this week, could make it much more difficult to provide high-quality CBD products in the U.S. The concern, as I can best articulate it since I’m not a farmer, is that full-spectrum CBD is largely available in plants that have a longer growth cycle, but these plants may also have THC levels above 0.3 percent by virtue of being in the ground for longer. Under current regulations, some farmers and producers have found ways to reduce the THC content following harvest, which allows them to sell full-spectrum CBD products with compliant THC levels. The new USDA regulations, though, require that the crop be tested for THC content 15 days prior to harvest. Any crops with an excess of THC will need to be discarded. This eliminates the possibility of growing for longer and eliminating excess THC after the fact.

I can’t speak personally to whether this perceived threat is real or overblown, but its one interesting example of the many consequences (intended or otherwise) the new federal regime will have on the industry.

One other, related, strain: Though hemp must have THC levels below 0.3 percent, these new rules create a couple of safe harbors. First, they recognize that testing labs have margins of error, and so if your crop tests at 0.34 percent THC, but the lab results have a 0.05 percent margin of error, then the crop is legal and you’re good to go. Second, if your crop is above 0.3 percent but below 0.5 percent THC, you can’t sell it, but you also won’t be prosecuted. These rules basically recognize the inherent uncertainty involved with growing hemp.

What Is Going on in the World of Hemp?

Anyone involved in the hemp and CBD industry in Maine has been on a roller coaster ride this year. On December 20, 2018, hemp became (kind of) legal federally. But then the U.S. Food and Drug Administration said that non-approved food products containing CBD remained illegal. Then Maine regulators started telling retailers that they weren’t allowed to sell food products containing CBD, only to walk that position back. In response, the State Legislature passed LD 630, which legalizes the sale of food products containing CBD. Meanwhile, at the federal level, the FDA appears to be taking the position that virtually any CBD product meant for human consumption is illegal. 

Where does this leave us? Folks in Maine appear to be safe from enforcement for the time being, with the notable exception of those who make explicit claims that CBD has therapeutic benefits. If you’re growing, processing, or selling hemp and CBD, though, it’s unlikely that the feds are going to knock down your door tomorrow, and LD 630 is keeping the State at bay for now. But watch out, because rulemaking is coming, and we’re sure to see rules that aim to limit the import (and perhaps the export?) of CBD products, create strict labeling and testing standards, and limit the use of CBD in animal food. There will be more details on a lot of the specifics here in future posts, but the situation is certainly fluid. 

Bottom line: Legalities aside, it seems to be full speed ahead in Maine, with a few notable restrictions. Avoid making public claims of therapeutic benefits (like "CBD cures cancer"). Make sure that your product is clean, free of mold and pesticides, etc. and has a THC content below 0.3 percent. Do what you can to ensure your product is accurately labeled. (Check out this study, which concludes that 70 percent of CBD products are inaccurately labeled in terms of CBD content.) And be aware of quickly changing laws and rules at the state and federal level that could impact your business.